Both pine shavings and straw are popular coop bedding choices, and each one works better in certain situations. If you’re new to chickens, choosing the right bedding can make chores easier and reduce smell.
Why This Topic Matters
Good bedding keeps moisture under control, makes eggs cleaner, and helps prevent odor. Choosing the wrong bedding for your climate can turn coop chores into a hassle.
Why You Can Trust This Guidance
I’ve used both materials in different seasons and coop sizes. This comparison is based on what’s worked well in real backyard setups along with common advice from other keepers.
Pine Shavings
Pros
- Great absorption
- Good smell control
- Easy to rake
- Works well in deep litter
Cons
- Can blow around
- Needs more frequent top ups
Straw
Pros
- Warm and insulating
- Hens like scratching in it
- Affordable in many rural areas
Cons
- Low absorption
- Mats down when wet
- Can mold in humid climates
Which Is Better Overall?
For most beginners, pine shavings are the easiest option because they handle moisture and smell better.
Straw works well if:
- you live in a dry climate
- you use it mostly in winter
- the coop is well ventilated
Step-by-Step: How to Choose
- Check your climate
- Think about your coop’s airflow
- Decide how often you want to clean
- Try each one for a month and compare
Mistakes to Avoid
- Using straw in damp coops
- Mixing straw with wet leaves
- Using cedar shavings
- Skipping ventilation
FAQs
Can I compost both?
Yes, they both break down well.
Is straw good for deep litter?
Only in dry climates.
Final Summary
Pine shavings are the more dependable bedding for most coops, while straw can work well in the right conditions. Try both and see which fits your routine best.